Electric Power Research Institute About Us
The Institute
Office Locations

2016 Corporate Social Responsibility Report

EPRI completed a full corporate social responsibility assessment in 2015 culminating in release of its first Corporate Social Responsibility report. The report (and companion video) provides a comprehensive look at EPRI's social responsibility culture and actions around four focus areas: community, employees, operations, and research.

Our Work Events Newsroom Careers EPRI Journal

Product Abstract

PRISM 2.0: Modeling Technology Learning for Electricity Supply Technologies

Product ID:3002000871
Date Published:19-Sep-2013
Pages:104
Sector Name:Environment
Document Type:Technical Results
Price:No Charge

This Product is publicly available

   1.81 MB - Adobe PDF (.pdf)

Abstract

The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) developed the U.S. Regional Economy, Greenhouse Gas, and Energy (US-REGEN) model, under the PRISM 2.0 Project. This model can assess the impact of various climate, energy, and environmental policies on the electric power sector, the energy system, and the overall U.S. economyThis report compares the technology learning rates implied by the exogenous cost specifications used in the US-REGEN model to those found in a literature review of observed learning curves.

Background

Understanding how the performance and cost of energy supply technologies changes over time is of key importance for analysts and decision-makers concerned with large-scale energy systems and their impacts on the economy and the environment. Studies over the past several decades have documented how the costs of energy technologies have evolved in the past. Based on historical data, researchers have proposed various types of “learning curves” (or experience curves) to relate the future cost of a technology to key parameters such as installed capacity, R&D spending levels, and other factors such as economies of scale, market structure, materials cost, and efficiency improvement.

The most widely used model of learning estimates the price or performance of a technology as a log-linear function of its cumulative installed capacity. While suitable for some situations, this model form provides an overly simplistic characterization of technological change, which in reality is driven by complex dynamic relationships involving multiple factors. Just what those factors are, however, and how they influence technology change, remains a subject of ongoing research. Furthermore, while the simple log-linear relationship between cost and installed capacity has been widely studied for some technologies such as wind and solar, this approach is ill-suited to projections for new technologies that are just gaining market share or have yet to be scaled up for commercial application.   

Objective

This report provides a comprehensive review of the recent literature on learning curves applicable to the electricity supply technologies available in the US-REGEN model to gain an understanding of the best ways to represent technological change in the model.

Approach

The report includes (1) a comprehensive literature review of technology learning models applicable to electric power generation technologies; (2) characterization of the state of the art and key findings stemming from that literature review; (3) review and characterization of other large-scale computer models that incorporate technology learning; and (4) from that review, lessons and insights potentially applicable to the development and use of EPRI’s REGEN model.

Results

The review found that there is a wide variation in reported learning rates. Some studies include both learning-by-doing and learning-by-researching (reflecting R&D spending) and report both values. In general, there are wide variations even within the same technologies and no clear trend of learning rates associated with a certain type of technology, time period, or region. Researchers found a narrower range of smaller learning rates associated with fossil power plants, whereas renewable technologies (wind, solar, biopower) have a wide range of learning rates including values as high as 45% to 53%. With the exception of nuclear power, all the studies reviewed report cost reductions with increased installed capacity.

There are two key categories of uncertainties associated with the application of experience curves. One is the learning curve itself; the other concerns the conclusions drawn from the use of learning curves. Because of these uncertainties, an expanded and more systematic use of sensitivity studies, especially the testing of alternative learning curve formulations, should be pursued to better and more fully characterize their implications for projected cost reductions and rates of technological change.

Application, Value, and Use

This report provides a comprehensive overview of current literature on learning curves and of the use of learning curves in a number of large-scale energy-economic models. The report will inform the reader of work that has already been conducted in the assessment of endogenous technology change and of key considerations for modeling technology improvements moving forward.

 

Program
2010 Program 181   PRISM 2.0
Keywords
  • Cost and performance
  • Technology evaluation
  • Technology trends
  • Endogenous learning curves
  • Exogenous learning curves
Report
000000003002000871
Note

For further information about EPRI, call the EPRI Customer Assistance Center at (800) 313-3774 or email askepri@epri.com

 Having Trouble Downloading?

Internet Explorer Information Bar

If using Internet Explorer the browser automatically blocks downloads by default, instead displaying an "Information Bar" at the top or bottom of the page.

Click "Download File" on Information Bar if using Internet Explorer 8 or older. If using version 9, click “Save” button on Information Bar and then select “Open” once downloaded.

Pop-up blocker software

You can hold down the CTRL key when selecting Download to bypass your pop-up blocker.

You may also configure your pop-up blocker to allow EPRI.com to open new windows.

Recommended Software

EPRI recommends using the latest version of Adobe Reader for best performance.

 Support Services

EPRI Customer Assistance Center (CAC):
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 4
askepri@epri.com

Hours of Operation:
8:00 AM - 6:00 PM Eastern Time (GMT-5)

Order and Conference Center:
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 2
orders@epri.com