Electric Power Research Institute About Us
The Institute
Office Locations

EPRI Summer Seminar

Each year, EPRI meets with executives and experts to discuss industry challenges and opportunities. Summer Seminar has played a crucial role in shaping EPRI’s research portfolio and the future of electricity worldwide.

Our Work
Electricity Generation
Electricity Delivery
Electricity Use
Environmental Responsibility

2015 Research Portfolio

See what programs and projects are on deck for next year. Visit our 2015 Research Portfolio.

Events
Calendars
This conference focuses on gaining insights from the unprecedented investments in Smart Grid deployments with a focus on Smart Grid successes, surprises and challenges in applying results and reaching beyond current deployments and into the future phases of grid modernization.
Newsroom Careers

Product Abstract

Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator (MISO) Energy Storage Study

Product ID:1024489
Date Published:29-Feb-2012
File size:1.45 MB
Sector Name:Power Delivery & Utilization
Document Type:Technical Update
FileType:Adobe PDF (.pdf)
Price:No Charge

This Product is publicly available.

Abstract
Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator (MISO) is a nonprofit member-based organization regulated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). As a Regional Transmission Organization (RTO), MISO provides electricity consumers in 13 states with regional grid management and open access to transmission facilities at a tariff closely regulated by FERC. MISO follows a cycle known as the MISO Transmission Expansion Plan (MTEP) that results in annual recommendations to proceed with expansion projects, subject to approval by the independent MISO board of directors. The Energy Storage Study—a targeted study carried out during the 2011 MTEP cycle—models several hypotheses surrounding pumped hydro storage (PHS), compressed air energy storage (CAES), and battery storage technologies and their impact on the MISO footprint. The study specifically explores reliability, market, and planning benefits that storage technologies could provide as well as the economic potential for storage technologies in MISO.

Background

In the MISO region—which includes all or most of North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and parts of Montana, Missouri, Kentucky, and Ohio—installed generation capacity is approximately 50% coal, 30% gas, 10% nuclear and 10% renewables. However, based on production costs in the region, the energy being produced is approximately 75% from coal, 15% from nuclear, and 10% from other sources. As a result of environmental mandates associated with coal plants and social choices in favor of renewable generation, MISO planners are being challenged to engage in more complex transmission studies that take regional and public policy variables into account. MISO's Energy Storage Study forms one part of this expanding agenda.

Objective

The Energy Storage Study objectives are to determine the economic potential for PHS, CAES, and battery storage technologies in the MISO region. The study will also estimate the price inflection point at which energy storage may become economically feasible. Finally, the study will suggest potential MISO energy and operating reserve markets enhancement products.

Approach

Three drivers provide the underpinnings of the MISO Energy Storage Study, as follows: 1) The ancillary services market (ASM) tariff needs a plan to accommodate long- and short-term storage technologies; 2) Increasingly, state renewable portfolio standards (RPS) programs mandate increases in energy use from renewable sources such as wind; and 3) MISO needs to improve storage modeling. During the Phase 1 study, MISO seeks first to evaluate the impact that additional stored energy resources could have on the MISO footprint and second to understand how that energy storage is best utilized. Two existing MISO planning models are used to identify these energy storage impacts. The first model is the Electric Generation Expansion Analysis System (EGEAS), designed by EPRI to determine the optimum (least-cost) integrated resource plan for a given demand level. The EGEAS model is used to identify circumstances when adding energy storage resources to the MISO footprint would be economically justified. The second model, a production cost model called PLEXOS, offers co-optimization functionality while modeling system-constrained economic dispatch in day-ahead and real-time markets with intra-hourly granularity. PLEXOS is used for deeper analysis to understand how energy storage resources can best be integrated in the MISO market. The Phase 1 study concentrated on modeling with EGEAS and involved some preliminary calibration and testing with PLEXOS.

Results

The Energy Storage Study provides valuable feedback and lessons learned about EGEAS and PLEXOS modeling tools and their suitability for assessing potential MISO benefits from energy storage. Following are some important conclusions:

  • Phase 1 of the Energy Storage Study has allowed MISO to become familiar with challenges inherent in modeling energy storage technology in a complex nodal market with an ASM. The study group has gained a good understanding about storage modeling using EGEAS, which is the primary MISO tool for transmission resource planning.
  • Study results demonstrate that there is economic potential for energy storage in the MISO footprint. Benefits were observed in cases using both EGEAS and PLEXOS. These benefits will be explored in greater depth during Phase 2.
  • Phase 1 results show that EGEAS is not the right tool to properly understand energy storage potential. Rather, the critical role for EGEAS is in identifying cases where storage is beneficial so that these cases can be analyzed further by PLEXOS in the Phase 2 study.
  • PLEXOS experience during Phase 1 has allowed for fine-tuning the model parameters, and important lessons were learned regarding storage model setup.

Application, Value and Use

MISO planning is evolving from an emphasis on reliability and resource adequacy to responses to new market and regulatory challenges. Key challenges confronting MISO include implementing new renewable energy policies, reducing grid congestion, and incorporating new generation and demand-side resources—all while still meeting load growth requirements. Overlying these newer challenges are an aging transmission infrastructure as well as the need to keep cost allocation fair. Considerable groundwork in such areas has been accomplished in Phase 1 of the Energy Storage Study. This report will provide valuable reference material for transmission planners throughout the industry.
Program
2012 Program 94  Energy Storage
Keywords
  • Battery storage
  • Compressed air energy storage (CAES)
  • Energy Storage
  • Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator (MISO)
  • Pumped Hydro Storage (PHS)
  • Renewable Resources
Report
000000000001024489
Note

For further information about EPRI, call the EPRI Customer Assistance Center at (800) 313-3774 or email askepri@epri.com

 

 Having Trouble Downloading?

 

Internet Explorer Information Bar

If using Internet Explorer the browser automatically blocks downloads by default, instead displaying an "Information Bar" at the top or bottom of the page.

Click "Download File" on Information Bar if using Internet Explorer 8 or older. If using version 9, click “Save” button on Information Bar and then select “Open” once downloaded.

Pop-up blocker software

You can hold down the CTRL key when selecting Download to bypass your pop-up blocker.

You may also configure your pop-up blocker to allow EPRI.com to open new windows.

Recommended Software

EPRI recommends using the latest version of Adobe Reader for best performance.

 

 Support Services

 

EPRI Customer Assistance Center (CAC):
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 4
askepri@epri.com

Hours of Operation:
8:00 AM - 7:00 PM Eastern Time (GMT-5)

Order and Conference Center:
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 2
orders@epri.com