Electric Power Research Institute About Us
The Institute
Office Locations

EPRI Summer Seminar

Each year, EPRI meets with executives and experts to discuss industry challenges and opportunities. Summer Seminar has played a crucial role in shaping EPRI’s research portfolio and the future of electricity worldwide.

Our Work Events
Calendars
This conference focuses on gaining insights from the unprecedented investments in Smart Grid deployments with a focus on Smart Grid successes, surprises and challenges in applying results and reaching beyond current deployments and into the future phases of grid modernization.
Newsroom Careers

Product Abstract

The Potential for Using Stormwater in Power Plants: Lessons Learned from Case Studies at Two Great River Energy Plants

Product ID:1023774
Date Published:14-Dec-2012
File size:1.64 MB
Sector Name:Environment
Document Type:Technical Report
FileType:Adobe PDF (.pdf)

This product is available at no cost to funding members only. If you are a member, you must Log in to access.

Price:$ 15,000 (US Dollars)

If you are a non-funding individual or entity and wish to purchase this document, please contact the EPRI Order Center at 1-800-313-3774 Option 2 or 650-855-2121. You may also send an e mail to orders@epri.com.

Abstract

Through detailed analyses for two power plants, this report evaluates the use of stormwater for cooling and other uses. The report will benefit environment, generation, and planning managers within power companies, government agencies, and water resource stakeholders.

Background

In recent years, there has been a focus on evaluating the use of nontraditional water sources for thermoelectric power plant cooling, such as reclaimed municipal wastewater, produced water from oil and gas drilling, and saline groundwater (described in EPRI report 1014935). These efforts are intended to minimize the freshwater footprint of current electricity generation and to develop alternative pathways for future generation growth in a water-constrained world. The current study was preceded by a scoping study (EPRI report 1021124) that examined stormwater generation across a range of climatic conditions, represented by 10 urban areas throughout the United States. Coupled with available data on stormwater quality from a national database, the scoping study identified treatment requirements for use in power plants. It concluded that stormwater could serve as a meaningful resource in certain power plant settings and for power plant uses with specific quality requirements, but that more site-specific analyses would be needed to consider water quality constraints; costs associated with conveyance, storage, and treatment; and discharge requirements.

Objective

This report provides guidance on assessing potential stormwater use at a generation plant by describing site-specific assessments conducted at two power plants.

Approach

Building on information obtained in the scoping study, this investigation focused on two power plants in detailed site-specific analyses. Both plants are owned by Great River Energy (GRE). The first is a 1,100-MW coal burning plant on the Missouri River in North Dakota (Coal Creek Generating Station); the second is a 37-MW refuse-derived fuel plant on the Mississippi River in Elk River, Minnesota (Elk River Energy Recovery Station). Analyses also considered a generating station with water demands similar to those of Coal Creek but placed in other climatic conditions (representing upstate New York, Illinois, and southern California). Therefore, the analyses presented pertain not only to the two plants, but also to plants with varying climatic drivers.

This report presents the methodological approach used to estimate stormwater flows, conveyance, and storage and treatment needs in a general plant setting in Section 2. A discussion of water quality and constraints related to discharge is presented in Section 3. Off-site and on-site stormwater volume estimates for the Coal Creek and Elk River stations are presented in Sections 4 and 5. The integration of stormwater flow, quality, treatment requirements, and costs is presented for Coal Creek Station in Section 6 and for Elk River Station in Section 7. Stormwater estimates and related calculations of their use for three hypothetical locations are presented in Section 8, and Section 9 presents the main findings of this study and their relevance to current and future electricity generation.

Results

For the two GRE plants considered, significant amounts of stormwater are available from both on-site and off-site sources. Water quality at these locations is acceptable from a process perspective for a variety of uses within power plants. The 1,100-MW Coal Creek plant may integrate stormwater into its water management using the existing infrastructure, with modest additional cost. Because the plant is spread over a large area, on-site stormwater provides a significant resource for use. The 37-MW Elk River station, at its current capacity, is not a good candidate for the use of stormwater either off- or on-site. It is, however, located near storm drains that convey substantial volume. If there is an increased need for water at this location (perhaps if a larger plant were built), the use of stormwater should be explored.

Following are general findings from this analysis, beyond the results for the two GRE plants:

  • Existing empirical tools can be used to estimate stormwater generation through modest computational effort, and the analysis developed for this work can be readily modified for other locations in North America.
  • Stormwater is a steady resource in regions and seasons in which rainfall is abundant. It is not a significant resource during dry or drought periods and may be an infrequent resource in arid areas.
  • The presence of a variety of added constituents in stormwater, specifically metals and organics, poses a problem from a discharge standpoint because these constituents will be further concentrated in discharge.
  • Costs of off-site stormwater conveyance through pipelines may limit use.

Applications, Value, and Use

As freshwater resources become more constrained by existing demands and needs for environmental protection, there is significant value in evaluating what might be considered a new water resource: stormwater. Stormwater is often seen as a flooding risk and not a potential water supply, but it is in some respects similar to municipal wastewater—a source often considered for replacing freshwater supply to power plants. Both sources are largely considered waste streams and must be collected and discharged with permits into surface waters. Stormwater does differ from municipal wastewater in terms of its quality and its highly variable volume and timing.
 

Program
2012 Program 55  Water Availability and Resource Risk Management
Keywords
  • Freshwater conservation
  • Freshwater resource sustainability
  • Generation plant water needs
  • Nontraditional water sources
  • Site-specific assessments
  • Stormwater uses
Report
000000000001023774
Note

For further information about EPRI, call the EPRI Customer Assistance Center at (800) 313-3774 or email askepri@epri.com

 

 Having Trouble Downloading?

 

Internet Explorer Information Bar

If using Internet Explorer the browser automatically blocks downloads by default, instead displaying an "Information Bar" at the top or bottom of the page.

Click "Download File" on Information Bar if using Internet Explorer 8 or older. If using version 9, click “Save” button on Information Bar and then select “Open” once downloaded.

Pop-up blocker software

You can hold down the CTRL key when selecting Download to bypass your pop-up blocker.

You may also configure your pop-up blocker to allow EPRI.com to open new windows.

Recommended Software

EPRI recommends using the latest version of Adobe Reader for best performance.

 

 Support Services

 

EPRI Customer Assistance Center (CAC):
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 4
askepri@epri.com

Hours of Operation:
8:00 AM - 7:00 PM Eastern Time (GMT-5)

Order and Conference Center:
800-313-3774 or 650-855-2121 Option 2
orders@epri.com